Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Animated Maps: The Way Forward?

I didn't make it to Google IO this year but have got a lot out of watching the Google maps talk videos.  One announcement they made was a new type of map element; 'symbols'. These enable developers to animate Google maps more.  Ed Parsons has bigged up the possibilities and I agree with him that animated maps have great potential and that there should be more use of animated maps.  At the moment they are nowhere near as common as simple map mashups.  I've been researching map animations recently so today I'll share some thoughts.

The potential of animation in Maps:   Any graphic or text needs to perform a number of functions:
  1. Catch the eye of the user
  2. Lead the eye around the graphic intuitively 
  3. Communicate effectively
  4. Produce a memorable and/or emotional response if possible

We can argue about how good this list is but I think its generally true (I've paraphrased it  from a book on graphic design 'White Space is not your Enemy').  

Movement always catches the eye (think blinking cursor) so map animations always do well at [1].  They can also be extremely effective at communicating effectively [3], the gap minder animation below is geographical information although strictly it isn't a map.  IMHO its very effective at communicating the story of how most countries have developed considerably in the 20th century and its also easy to pick out individual countries from the animation.



I also like this animation of the spread of post offices in the US (although its probably better watched at a higher resolution than I have here)





Downsides to Animation in Maps. However, there are a number of problems with animations.  

- Going, Going, Gone:  Unlike a static graphic, the information is only visible for a fixed amount of time so the user has to see the information, make sense of it and remember it before the animation moves on.  With a well designed graphic, such as Edward Tufte's diagram showing the development of storm clouds, all the information is available for review and elements are constantly visible.



one of the nice aspects of the post office map above is that it keeps the dots on screen after they've appeared which mitigates this problem somewhat.
- Pat Head, Rub Belly:  The kids game of trying to pat your head and rub your belly at the same time illustrates another problem known as split attention - we find it difficult to do or follow multiple things happening at once.  An example is the map based animation at 55 seconds in this clip showing rainfall and taxi location at once.






Solutions:  There are a few solutions to these problems:

- Simplify Icons/other symbology:  Animated maps need to be simplified as much as possible, an easy examples include making icons plain shapes such as rather than a more meaningful bike shaped icon.  The background map on which the data is being animated can also be simplified e.g. removing colored roads.  The post office map above is a good example of both of these things.
- Play Slowly:  In complex parts, slow down the speed the animation is playing at.  This needs to be done with clear signalling otherwise they could miss that it was happening. 
- Annotate:  If something interesting is happening on a screen full of changing data (the split attention problem) a labelled arrow drawing the user's eye to the correct location on screen can be very helpful.

Conclusion:  Map animations can be very powerful but they need to be implemented carefully with a user centered focus.  See this post for more detail and Mark Harrower's discussion

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Apple Maps and 3D

So since I last posted here there has been a lot of to and fro about 3D in mobile maps.  I won't get into discussing the Google vs Apple rivalry as this has been well discussed elsewhere .  What I'm interested in is what is the long term value of 3D on maps.  Consider this video



it shows two 3D features I want to discuss here, 3D full color and 3D grey blocks.   I've discussed these issues before but its worth revisiting considering the new Apple example.   The full color IMHO is just showy, I can't see people pulling up this kind of imagery on their mobile devices whilst on the move, its just too visually complex.  I think everyone is going to play with it when they first see it on a device and then revert to something more visually simple when completing navigation tasks.

The more interesting feature is the 3D gray blocks.  Of course these aren't an Apple breakthrough, they've been on Google maps for a while:



Gray blocks for buildings (either of the Google or Apple variety) are visually simpler than full colored buildings and so may form an extra layer of information which users can use to navigate with.  I think the simple Apple gesture needed to make 3D snap on or off is good, this may make it something users can turn on when they are on the move and think it could help them navigate.

However, I think the buildings examples used in the demo had distinctive shapes so the grey blocks view looks very effective.  The feature may be much less use in a more normal city scape where building shapes are squarer and much more uniform.  So for navigating around a city, I'm yet to be convinced 3D gray blocks are a game changer.  And of course, out of the city, the feature really loses its value as buildings big enough to act as landmarks are much rarer.

More interesting is when navigation moves indoors, then shape of rooms and corridors becomes much more important for navigation IMHO.

Thursday, May 24, 2012

GOV.UK and Maps

Posts have been thin on the ground recently because I've been busy teaching a new course at the Uni.  However, its all over bar the exam marking now so I'm hoping to be more active here.

A friend has been involved in putting together GOV.UK - a site that provides the public with information from the British Government and acts as a clearing house to councils and other public bodies.  I really like the site, one of the key characteristics is that the designers have clearly focussed on user's needs.  I've had a quick whizz around looking for ways maps are, or could be, implemented in the site and a few thoughts spring to mind:

One Map, Many Points:   In the neighborhood section of the map you can enter your postcode and find services around you.  The site delivers you a list of possible local services, in the example below, we're looking at computer training courses:


As you can see, you get an individual map for each location.  It would be much better to provide one map with all the suggested services as markers with a linked list to the left of the screen (much as Google Maps and other services already deliver search results) with your entered post code shown as well.  This would enable the user to see which service is closer or if its close to their work commute route.

A nice add on to this would be travel time estimation circles centered on the entered postcode as found on TFL's 'Why not Walk It' maps.

Map Wiki: I also noticed that the site doesn't link users to useful map wiki or VGI (Volunteered Geographic Information) web sites such as FixMyStreet.  This enables the public to easily alert councils in the UK to problems with public spaces such as fly tipping or potholes because they interface with a map which is much easier than filling in a form.  I suspect that the remit for gov.uk limits their ability to have done this since they link out to councils sites for this sort of service and councils may or may not have chosen to use a site like FixMyStreet.  

Map as Spine:  The way GOV.UK is organized is centered around search and text based categories.  There's nothing wrong with this structure, I'm sure its what most people want to use.  However, I wonder if a map based structuring would add value as an extra way of organizing the data?  Instead of entering the site wondering how to answer a specific question, maybe people would like to mine the information to make broader decisions such as where in London would I like to move to?  A series of maps based on each area could be very useful showing people how well an area is serviced by the public sector and data from within the site could be used to populate the map.


Thursday, April 26, 2012

Color Blindness and Color Blends

I came across these color blends in a post on the web today (to save blushes, I'm not linking) from a mapping developer.  Here's what they look like to the majority of us



and here's how 6% of the male population see it (via the excellent color oracle freeware)


clearly the bottom two blends will be very difficult for color blind users to interpret.

Color blindness is a lot more complex than I've explained here but generally blends from yellow to blue are much better than reds to greens.  More info on color blindness in maps here.

If you're interested in the more general uses of color in maps, the Haklay text book has a good couple of chapters.

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

Usability Problems with Zeros on Cluster Maps

Please excuse the lack of post recently, I've been particularly busy with teaching over the last month.

Some Experimental Results: My PhD student Craig has some results from a usability experiment on the UK Crime Maps site.  It's too early in the analysis to discuss in detail but one aspect is coming across very clearly: users are getting confused by the representation of postcodes with no crimes on cluster maps (explanation of cluster maps).




Problem:  When you zoom in on an area in the crime map, you are presented with a view as on the left.  The number of crimes in the last month is shown for each postcode as a number in a blob, e.g. for the postcode mid left (above Thurleigh Rd) there were 4 crimes.  The problem with this visualisation is that the boundaries of the postcodes aren't visible.  If you look on the right I've illustrated roughly where two of the postcodes are with dotted red lines.  The postcode on the left has 1 crime, the one on the right (Devereux Rd) has none and so hasn't got a blob at all.

When users were asked to pick out the postcode with the least crime on the actual crime map (left) they failed to understand that no blob = no crime and identified the blob with the lowest number as the postcode with the lowest crime.

Solution:  On collated point maps zero crime postcodes should be represented by blobs with zeros in them.  

Thursday, March 1, 2012

Colour in Maps

On my other blog I've previously touched on the use of color in maps:

In researching my currently running course on communicating with web maps I came across some other best practices, mostly via the chapter on color in Muki Haklay's book.




Background = Blue:  We evolved doing things like picking berries from bushes in Africa, its therefore not surprising that the natural background color of that African landscape, the blue of the sky, is one as one that we still naturally associate with background.  Note how the red water above comes forward compared to the blue version and swamps out the map detail around it (map courtesy OSM)



Color Wheel Opposites:  The color wheel is a representation of 'color space' with hue around the edge. When choosing colors for symbols (such as placemarks) that need to visually stand out from each other, choose colors opposite each other on the color wheel.  A well used variation of this is yellow and blue.


Thursday, February 16, 2012

Basemaps and Learning Curves

I'm up against the wall in terms of time still so short blog post today on a couple of topics both via James Fee.

Subtle Basemaps:  one of the basic problems with mashups has been putting data over a map designed for route planning.  Recently with Google maps API v3 and tools like tile mill people have started de-emphacizing background maps so that the data stands out better against the background map.  I agree with James that the OSM bright minimal style is a interesting development in this line of work.


I'd love to see some user test results to see how people fared working with a mashup based on this base map.

Learning Curves:  Also via James I read a great quote about teaching OS mapping software to students.
"One of the trepidations I have with teaching mapping courses using open source is that it usually requires some modicum of programming which is always way beyond the scope of any beginner class about making maps.  In addition, open source tends to favor linux or unix based tool chains that require config/make/make install tap dance before starting anything. This is akin to telling folks that they will need to forge their tools before they can start building a dog house."
Amen to that (emphasis mine).  I'm teaching web cartography at the moment mostly using Google Earth because I want them to learn about color, symbology and chart junk, not some abstract javascript that they will forget a week after the course is over.

The rest of the post goes on to explain why Sophia thinks TileMill for windows is a game changer.